论航空事故调查报告诉讼证明问题

详细信息

Evidence Properties of Final Civil Aircraft Accident Investigation Report

Law School, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100191, China

摘要: 民用航空器事故调查报告对于事故相关民事诉讼的事实查清具有重要作用,有必要探讨其证据属性.研究以实证为基础,从分析调查报告的特性入手,进而将其与书证等法定证据种类进行辨析,最终提出并论证了调查报告的证据属性为行政主体认定的免证事实,证据效力需辨证分析和适用的观点.
- 民用航空器事故 /
- 证据属性 /
- 免证事实 /
- 证据材料 /
- 诉讼
Abstract: Civil aircraft accident investigation report is of great importance in indentifying accident related facts. It is necessary to explore its evidence property. As an empirical study, the article first analyzes the characteristics of investigation report, and then compares it with documentary evidence and other types of legal evidence. Lastly, the article proposes and demonstrates that the investigation report approved by the administrative body is proof of facts without evidence, and its effectiveness needs to be dialectically analyzed and applied.
- civil aircraft accident /
- evidence properties /
- proof of facts without evidence /
- evidence material /
- litigation

[1]	张蕾.包头空难索赔立案3年后终开庭人均索赔超400万[N]. 北京晚报,2012-10-09(9).
[2]	National Transportation Safety Board. Aircraft accident report uncontrolled descent and collision with terrain USAir Flight 427 Boeing 737-300,N513AU [EB/OL].[2014-03-03].
[3]	张凯,李勇. 国际航空事故调查政策法规的发展对我国民航的影响[J].中国民用航空,2012(8):46-47.
[4]	张晓鸥. 美国民用航空器事故医学调查简介[J].中华航空航天医学杂志, 2001,12(3):60-62.
[5]	张栋."交通事故责任认定书"的证据属性[J].中国司法鉴定,2009(2): 72-74.
[6]	赵信会.对交通事故认定书证据属性的质疑[J]. 法学论坛, 2009,24(6): 116-120.
[7]	刘品新.交通事故认定书存在明显错误其法律效力如何认定?[J].中国审判,2008(3): 68-69.
[8]	杜志淳.司法鉴定实验教程[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2009:3.
[9]	刘金友.证据法学[M]. 北京:中国政法大学出版社,2001:146-150.
[10]	郝秀梅,刘海安,杨万柳.航空保险法[M]. 北京:法律出版社,2012: 352.
[11]	Rapoport Law Offices, P.C. Aviation accidents: frequently asked questions[EB/OL]. [2014-03-03].
[12]	Baum Hedlund Aristei, Goldman P C. Pilot's reaction among flight 3407 crash causes[EB/OL]. [2014-03-03].
[13]	中国国际航空公司4·15釜山空难调查结果公布[EB/OL]. [2014-03-03].