ISSN 1008-2204
CN 11-3979/C

法秩序统一视角下刑事违法判断的要点

Main Points of Criminal Illegality Judgment from the Perspective of Unified Legal Order

  • 摘要: 法秩序统一是指国家现行所有部门法规范之间应当保持协调一致,要求一个部门法规定的合法行为不应当被另一个部门法评价为违法行为,这是现代化法治进程中需要贯彻落实的重要原理。但基于不同部门法规范调整范围和任务的差异性,法秩序统一至今尚未得到实现。通过分析法秩序统一理论和违法关系论,对刑事违法性判断应当认可一种缓和的违法相对论。虽然刑法是民法、行政法等其他部门法规范的后置法,但是刑法的后置性并不意味着刑事违法性判断从属于前置法违法性判断。法秩序统一视角下的刑事违法性判断应当具有相对独立性。刑事违法性判断基于三阶层犯罪论体系整体独立,行为具备刑事违法性是指具备构成要件该当性和违法性,而并非在前置法上被评价为违法。刑事违法性判断的独立性是相对的,前置法上合法是阻却刑事违法性的事由,具体表现为在构成要件该当性或违法性阶层发挥其“出罪”的功能和价值。

     

    Abstract: The unity of legal order means that all current departmental laws and regulations should maintain coordination and consistency, requiring that acts deemed lawful under one departmental law should not be evaluated as illegal under another departmental law. This is an important principle that must be implemented in the process of modernizing the rule of law in China. However, due to the differences in the regulatoryscopes and tasks of various departmental laws, the unity of legal order has not been fully realized. By analyzing the unified theory of legal order and the theory of illegality relations, a moderated theory of relative illegality should be recognized for the judgment of criminal illegality. Although criminal law serves as a post-law to civil law, administrative law, and other legal norms, the posterior character of criminal law does not imply that the judgment of criminal illegality is subordinate to the illegality judgment under the antecedent laws. The judgment of criminal illegality from the perspective of the unified legal order should possess relative independence. The judgment is based on the overall independence of the tripartite crime theory system. A conduct possesses criminal illegality when it satisfies both the constitutive elements and the element of illegality, rather than being merelyevaluated under the antecedent laws. The independence of the judgment of criminal illegality is relative; legality under the antecedent laws constitutes a ground for excluding criminal illegality. This is specifically embodied in the function and value of "decriminalizing", which operates at the level of either constitutive elements conformity or illegality.

     

/

返回文章
返回