拿来之后——期待可能性本土化之思考

详细信息

Reflection on the Localization of Expected Possibility Theory

School of Law, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100191, China

摘要: 期待可能性理论有坚实的哲学和法理基础,在关注人性、体现刑法谦抑性和发挥刑罚功能等方面具有强大的理论吸引力,但是也存在对罪刑法定原则可能构成潜在危害,对法官素质具有较高要求,对完善的配套法律制度较为依赖等问题。因此,引进该理论应当慎重,应当在明确该理论在中国犯罪构成中的地位、在中国刑法和刑法理论中的功能,并设置相应的程序保障后再予以适用。
- 期待可能性 /
- 人性 /
- 谦抑 /
- 困境 /
- 本土化
Abstract: Expected possibility theory has solid philosophical and legal theoretical basis which has great interests in the aspects of human nature, restrained principle of criminal law and the function of penalty. However, this theory may also constitute potential hazard to the principle of legally prescribed punishment for a specified crime, and has high quality requirements of the judges, and relies much more on a perfect matching legal system. Based on these perspectives, the introduction of this theory should be cautious.It should not be applied until it has a clear position in the system of Constitution of Crime in China as well as the set of approprate procedural guarantee.
- expected possibility /
- human nature /
- restrained principle of criminal law /
- dilemma /
- localization

[1]	休谟.人性论［M］.关文运,译.北京:商务印书馆,1991:6.
[2]	陈兴良.刑法的人性基础［M］.北京:中国方正出版社,1996:1.
[3]	大塚仁.刑法论集:1［M］.北京:有斐阁,昭和53年:240.
[4]	林山田.刑罚学［M］.台北:商务印书馆,1985:127.
[5]	李立众,刘代华.期待可能性理论研究［J］.中外法学,1999(1).
[6]	李斯特. 德国刑法教科书:修订译本［M］.徐久生,译.北京:法律出版社,2006:312.
[7]	陈兴良,周光权,刑法学的现代展开［M］.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006.
[8]	大谷实.刑法总论［M］.黎宏,译.北京:法律出版社,2003.
[9]	李立众.中日刑事法学术研讨会纪实 //冯军.比较刑法研究.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2007:485.
[10]	汉斯海 ·因里希 ·耶赛克,托马斯 ·魏根特.德国刑法教科书［M］. 徐久生,译.北京:中国法制出版社,2001:603.
[11]	刘鹏.大陆法系刑法学期待可能性理论评介［M］//刘鹏.刑事法学研究.北京:中国人民公安大学出版社,2006:1-10.
[12]	廖梅.积极审慎引进期待可能性理论 .检察日报,2004-07-11(4).
[13]	苏惠渔.刑法学［M］.北京:中国政法大学出版社,1997:263-264.
[14]	内藤谦.刑法讲义总论:下［M］.东京:有斐阁,1991:1103.
[15]	刘艳红.调节性刑罚恕免事由:期待可能性理论的功能定位［J］.中国法学,2009,(4).
[16]	刘远.期待可能性［M］.北京:北京大学出版社,2009.