一场旷日持久且远未结束的论战 ——美国学界有关社会保障对储蓄影响的争论述评

孙永勇; 赵洪燕

一场旷日持久且远未结束的论战 ——美国学界有关社会保障对储蓄影响的争论述评

孙永勇¹,
赵洪燕²

1.
中国社会科学院世界经济与政治研究所, 北京 100732
2. 华中师范大学公共管理学院, 湖北武汉 430079

详细信息

作者简介:
孙永勇 (1975—),男,湖北襄阳人,副教授,博士,研究方向为社会保障理论与政策.

中图分类号: C913.7
计量
- 文章访问数: 848
- HTML全文浏览量: 0
- PDF下载量: 548
出版历程
- 收稿日期: 2012-05-07
- 发布日期: 2013-07-24

A Long-drawn-out Polemic that is Far from Over: a Review of the Controversy about the Effect of Social Security on Savings in American Academia

Sun Yongyong¹,
Zhao Hongyan²

1.
The Institute of World Economics and Politics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Beijing 100732
2. College of Public Administration, Central China Normal University, Wuhan 430079, China

摘要

摘要: 早在20世纪60年代,美国学术界就开始关注社会保障对储蓄的影响.但直到1974年费尔德斯坦提出社会保障使美国私人储蓄减少了很多之后,有关这个问题的争论才开始白热化.许多知名专家学者投入到这一问题的研究中,提出了各种分析方法和观点,但直到现在也没有得出公认的结论.美国学术界有关这个问题的论战,实质是社会保障改革道路之争.人们不应该盲从于某种观点,更不应该急于把某一种观点当作支持自己社会保障改革主张的依据,而是应该汲取其在研究方法等方面的营养,继续前行.
- 社会保障 /
- 储蓄 /
- 挤出效应 /
- 内需
Abstract: Back in the 1960s, the effect of social security on savings had been concerned by American academia. But it was only after Feldstein pointed out that social security had reduced private savings greatly in America until 1974 that the controversy about this problem came to a white heat. Many famous pundits threw themselves into investigation about this problem, brought forward a variety of analytical methods and viewpoints, but an acknowledged conclusion has not come into being until today. US academia debate on this problem is the dispute of social security reform road in essence. So we should not pander to a viewpoint like sheep, particularly should not be anxious to take a viewpoint as the basis for their proposition of social security reform, But should learn from their research methods, absorb the advantages and keep moving on.
- social security /
- savings /
- Crowded-out Effect /
- domestic market demand

HTML全文

参考文献(38)

[1]	Philip Cagan. The effect of pension plans on aggregate saving: evidence from a sample survey . .
[2]	George Katona. Private pensions and individual savings[M]. Ann Arbor, Michigan:University of Michigan Press, 1965: 6.
[3]	Henry Aaron. Social security: international comparisons //Otto Eckstein. Studies in the economics of income maintenance. Washington D C: Brookings Institute, 1967: 19.
[4]	Martin Feldstein. Social security, induced retirement and aggregate capital accumulation [J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1974,82(5):905—926.
[5]	Herry Aaron. Economic effects of social security[M]. Washington, D C: The Brookings Institution Press, 1982:3—8.
[6]	Michael J Boskin. Social security and retirement decisions[J]. Economic Inquiry, 1977, 15(1):1—25.
[7]	Michael J Boskin. Too many promises: the uncertain future of social security[M]. Homewood: Dow Jones-Irwin, 1986: 62.
[8]	Pellechio A J. Social security financing and retirement behavior [J]. American Economic Review, 1979,69(2):284—287.
[9]	Sheldon Danziger, Robert Haveman, Robert Plotnick. How income transfer payments affect work, saving, and the income distribution: a critical review [J]. Journal of Economic Literature, 1981,19(9):975—1021.
[10]	Peter A Diamond. A framework for social security analysis [J]. Journal of Public Economics, 1977,8(3): 275—298.
[11]	Robert C Merton. On the role of social security as a means for efficient risk sharing in an economy where human capital is not tradeable //Zvi Bodie, John B Shoven , David A Wise. Issues in Pension Economics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1983: 147—169.
[12]	Andrew B Abel. Precautionary saving and accidental bequests [J]. American Economic Review, 1985,75(4):777—791.
[13]	Hubbard R Glenn. Uncertain lifetimes, pensions and individual saving //Zvi Bodie, John B Shoven, David A Wise. Issues in Pension Economics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1987:175—210.
[14]	Laurence J Kotlikoff, John B Shoven, Avia Spivak. Annuity markets, savings, and the capital stock //Zvi Bodie, John B Shoven ,David A Wise. Issues in Pension Economics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1987:211—234.
[15]	Hubbard R Glenn ,Kenneth L Judd. Social security and individual welfare: precautionary saving, borrowing constraints, and the payroll tax[J]. American Economic Review, 1987,77(4): 630—646.
[16]	Alicia Munnell. Private pensions and saving: new evidence[J]. Journal of Public Economics, 1976,84(5): 1013—1032.
[17]	Hubbard R Glenn, Kenneth L Judd. Liquidity constraints, fiscal policy, and consumption[J]. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1986(1):1—50.
[18]	Dean R Leimer ,Selig D Lesnoy. Social security and private saving: new time series evidence[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1982,90(3):606—629.
[19]	Robert J Barro. The impact of social security on private saving: evidence from the United States time series[M]. Washington D C: American Enterprise Institute, 1978: 47.
[20]	Robert J Barro, Glenn M Macdonald. Social security and consumer spending in an international cross section[J]. Journal of Public Economics, 1979,11(3):275—290.
[21]	Laurence J Kotlikoff, Avia Spivk. The family as an incomplete annuities market[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1981,89(2):372—391.
[22]	Edna Louise Clark Wentworth, Dena Motley. Resources after retirement:a study of income, assets, and living arrangements of social security beneficiaries, 1941 through 1962 . . FTL57335GHM7UV1H53R7NJX2R4VNSYF-21441?func=full-set-set&set_number=009490&set_entry=000001&format=999.
[23]	Social Security Administration. Monograph No. 34 office of research and statistics research report . Washington D C: US Government Printing Office, 1970.
[24]	Michael R Darby. Postwar US consumption, consumer expenditures, and saving[J]. American Economic Review, 1975, 65(2):217—222.
[25]	Michael R Darby. The consumer expenditure function . .
[26]	Martin Feldstein. Social security and saving: new time series evidence . .
[27]	Richard Thaler, Hersh Shefrin. Quasi rational economics[M]. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 1991:91—127.
[28]	James Poterba, Steven Venti, David Wise. How retirement saving programs increase saving[J].Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1996,10(4):91—112.
[29]	Jonathan Skinner. Individual retirement accounts: a review of the evidence . .
[30]	Douglas Bernheim B,Jonathan Skinner, Steven Weinberg. What accounts for the variation in retirement wealth among US households . .
[31]	Levin Lawrence. Are assets fungible? testing alternative theories of life-cycle savings[J]. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 1998,36(1): 59—83.
[32]	David Laibson. Hyperbolic discounting functions, undersaving, and savings policy . .
[33]	David Laibson, George Marios Aneletos, Andrea Repetto, et al. The hyperbolic consumption model: calibration, simulation, and empirical evaluation[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2001,15(3):47—68.
[34]	David I Laibson, Andrea Repetto, Jeremy Tobacman. Self-control and saving for retirement[J]. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1998,29(1):91—196.
[35]	Douglas B Bernheim,John Karl Scholz. Private saving and public policy //James M Poterba. Tax Policy and the Economy: Vol.7. Cambridge: MIT Press, 1993:73—110.
[36]	William G Gale. The effects of pensions on wealth: a re-evaluation of theory and evidence[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1998,106(4):706—723.
[37]	Karen E Dynan, Jonathan Skinner , Stephen P Zeldes. Do the rich save more[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 2004,112(2):397—444.
[38]	The Kaiser Family Foundation. Explaining the basics of health reform . (2009-05-20) .

施引文献

资源附件(0)

计量

文章访问数: 848
HTML全文浏览量: 0
PDF下载量: 548
被引次数: 0

一场旷日持久且远未结束的论战 ——美国学界有关社会保障对储蓄影响的争论述评

作者简介: 孙永勇 (1975—),男,湖北襄阳人,副教授,博士,研究方向为社会保障理论与政策.

计量

出版历程

A Long-drawn-out Polemic that is Far from Over: a Review of the Controversy about the Effect of Social Security on Savings in American Academia

计量

出版历程

目录

作者简介:
孙永勇 (1975—),男,湖北襄阳人,副教授,博士,研究方向为社会保障理论与政策.